Blog Carnivals and my ‘Makes-Me-Smile Monday’ Post
May 14th, 2007 | Posted in Blogging |
My wife Shannon has really gotten into blogging lately. It brings out the writer in her and reminds me of when we were first dating and sending e-mail to each other every day. In her blog, Shannon has hit upon an interesting concept called the Blog Carnival. The blog carnival is a way of getting everyone in your blogging circle to make a special post about a particular topic on a certain day. For example, the Rocks in My Dryer blog (Shannon’s inspiration for the idea) has a regular “Works-for-Me Wednesday” post, in which the author announces a theme for the week, and everyone is supposed to write a post on that theme on Wednesday. (The “works-for-me” adjective refers to a tip that works for you (which you post on Wednesday)).
Everyone in the Rocks in My Dryer site adds their post (via a tool called Mister Linkey) to the bottom of the original Rocks-in-My-Dryer-Works-for-Me-Wednesday post. The links from the participants look like this:
Carnivals provide community and structure to the blogging experience. You aren’t just reading a random posts on topics you subscribed to. You have entered into a community of people organized around a common theme. I think it’s quite cool. Here’s the Wikipedia definition:
A Blog Carnival is a type of blog event. It is similar to a magazine, in that it is dedicated to a particular topic, and is published on a regular schedule, often weekly or monthly. Each edition of a blog carnival is in the form of a blog article that contains permalinks links to other blog articles on the particular topic.
There are many variations, but typically, someone who wants to organize a carnival posts details of the theme or topic to their blog, and asks readers to submit relevant articles for inclusion in an upcoming edition. The host then collects links to these submissions, edits and annotates them (often in very creative ways), and publishes the resulting round-up to his or her blog.
(Actually, in reading the Wikipedia entry, the carnival seems more like “synchronized blogging,” which it says is a variant, but the concepts are nearly the same.)
Anyway, blog carnivals are not only a neat idea, they have tremendous potential to influence Google search rankings. The blog carnival organizer benefits most (the Rocks in my Dryer author is ranked around 240 in Technorati — this is near “blogebrity” status). But so does each individual participating in the carnival, because the blog organizer is linking to each of them (through the Mister Linkey feature, shown in the image above).
I would like to start up a regular “Tech Writing Tips for Tuesdays” carnival, and I think I just may do it.
My Makes-Me-Smile Monday Post
So here’s my Makes-Me-Smile Monday post, linked back to Shannon’s original post. The theme is what makes me smile about my mother (mothers is the theme).
My mother has taught me more about generosity and patience than I can do justice here describing. But what makes me “smile” right now is somewhat trivial — I’m thinking about the signature foods my mom makes. As a kid growing up, my mother would always call me into the kitchen so that I could see how she was making this or that. For example, she would say, Tom, here’s how you make a white cream sauce for these peas. You just add some of this white powder stuff (forgot the name), add some milk, and stir. Notice I keep stirring so that it doesn’t burn. … (You get the picture.)
As a kid, I thought this was torture. However, the other week my mom was here in a family gathering and she brought some food with her: cooked candied apples. I hadn’t eaten cooked candied apples for 10 years or more, and it made me think about all the other food that I associate only with my mother: the peas in white sauce, egg custard, the egg nog with nutmeg, bread crumbs over noodle casserole, candied apples, runny eggs over toast cut into little squares, and more.
What makes me smile is that while I never enjoyed the kitchen lessons, I look back on the food and realize that I fondly associate this food uniquely and distinctly with my mother.
It seems everyone has a few unique dishes — food that is unique to you, and only you. My dad makes some crazy curry dishes. My wife makes chicken taco pie. I make orange-julius shakes. Avery makes peanut-butter and jelly sandwiches. I attach certain foods to the memories of certain people in ways stronger than I imagined.
Happy Mother’s Day!
Take a ride down Writer River, a social news site for technical communicators.
Related Posts
- Special Father’s Day Post: Description of My Dad
- If I Had Ten Days to Live …
- The Best and Worst of Times with a Hard Headed Woman
- Lucy Smiles for the Camera — Funny Photo
- Free Doc Train Ticket ($899) for Your Response to a Question About Innovation
Podcast in iTunes
Follow me on Twitter

May 15th, 2007 at 2:08 pm
As you stated, WFMW isn’t a carnival. A blog carnival would be like the Carnival of Family Life, hosted this week by Be A Good Dad (http://www.beagooddad.com/421/carnival-of-family-life-mothers-day-edition/).
Also note that Mister Linky (no e) doesn’t provide actual HTML links, it generates JavaScript links. (Actual blog carnivals usually do provide HTML links.) WFMW isn’t moderated; blog carnivals may or may not be. IMO, the best ones are moderated at least a little.
There’s an entire website devoted to blog carnivals—blogcarnival.com.
May 16th, 2007 at 8:06 am
Jordan — WFMW is at least a little moderated in that the site author “reserves the right to delete links that are inappropriate.” She also threatens to delete “empty” links. I’ve found the blogcarnival.com site to be a little hard to navigate. I wish it organized carnivals by category, not just date.
Is there a bloggy term for things like WFMW if not “blog carnival”? And is the distinction one of degree or kind?
May 16th, 2007 at 10:19 am
Shannon (of RIMD) actually does call it a blog carnival. I usually refer to it as a meme (obviously without tagging). It doesn’t fit either definition perfectly.
I don’t know… maybe we should just make up a new word. A “memival.”
I’ve only found one blog carnival from blogcarnival.com that I contribute to (aforementioned Carnival of Family Life; I’m told it’s one of the best). Seems like most of them are inactive.
May 16th, 2007 at 12:42 pm
Nooooooo — I refuse to be an instigator of a meme! How did meme come to be called that anyway? Not much in common with the definition of “the cultural equivalent of a gene.”
Do people get rejected from carnivals on the grounds of poor literary quality? Or is it usually just a check to make sure they’re appropriate to the topic/audience?
May 16th, 2007 at 12:58 pm
‘Meme’ comes from the ancient Greek term ‘memetics.’ The word ‘meme’ is actually 30 years old (never would have guessed it). I think that a better definition is the cultural equivalent of a virus (but not necessarily a bad one), though I’ve heard the gene analogy before.
I don’t know if blog carnivals reject entrants because of poor quality, though I’d guess that some do. Thankfully none I’ve been a part of.
You can call your own thing whatever you want, of course. Call it a carnival if you like. It doesn’t fit my neat little definition of a carnival, but that’s okay. I’m not the blogging police.
May 20th, 2007 at 1:10 am
Neil Gaiman: The Nature of the infectionJobs surges ahead with new productUniversal search: The best answer is still the best answerJonathan Schwartz: Free Advice for the Litigious…Fiji: Blocking out democracyBlog Carnivals and my ‘Makes-Me-Smile Monday’ PostPeter Jackson and Stephen Spielberg teaming up to make a Tintin trilogy (!)Some Photographs From the Wedding of the Greatest Living Englishman and Melinda Perry GebbieKaliyuga Kronicles: The Blair Years: The Critical Moments
March 5th, 2008 at 12:27 am
[...] Blog Carnivals and my ‘Makes Me Smile Monday’ Post | I’d Rather Be Writing said: [...]